Have you ever tried to read a book as someone shouts directly into your ear? If you ask me, it would be possible, but quite strenuous and unpleasant. That being said, do you know anyone who would even tolerate, let alone request that someone shout into their ear as they try to write an essay, read a book or solve mathematical equations?
As funny as it sounds, this scenario is not as uncommon as one might think. All you have to do is add a couple of bells and whistles and even further-distracting noises to the shouting, and you now know what it’s like to try to do schoolwork with your MP3 player screaming into your ears at full blast.
There are a number of studies that suggest that listening to certain types of music can help someone study better. I do not disagree, but I would like to stress that this is only with certain types of music. I think that any credible person would agree that the brain reacts in a different way from listening to a relaxing concerto, than it does from hearing a rapper spit out profanities a mile a minute. I do not think that music is a problem if it is listened to at an appropriate time, but I think that it can negatively affect someone’s concentration if they are listening to it while trying to do something important such as school work (especially if it is the distracting, high-energy type of music that is popular nowadays).
I think that while studying unsupervised, most students lack the will power to keep their music turned off. Their music makes them feel good, so it is difficult for them to make the choice between feeling good, and being able to concentrate better.
One thing that really bothers me is when people crank up their earphones when I’m next to them trying to study. With an Apple iPod capable of reaching a volume level of 115 decibels, there is 'second-hand noise' aplenty in a room where someone has theirs playing at a moderate to high volume. I am extremely grateful for my current school's strict “no music” policy, but I was not as lucky last year and I found it extremely stressful to constantly ask students to turn down their music as the teachers said nothing.
Overall, it’s none of my business if you want to play your music when you’re by yourself trying to study, but you should, for your own benefit, honestly think about whether or not it is going to have a negative affect on your productivity. I know that it can be quite tempting to listen to your tunes when no one is there to tell you not to.
Thank you to all of the schools with “no-music” policies, and no-thanks to people who disturb their fellow classmates by blasting their earphones during class.
Thank you and happy 2010 Olympic games everybody!
Music can be good to listen
Music can be good to listen to while doing homework, but you should not listen to music full blast. If I ever listen to music I usually put it at a volume that wont distract me, instead of blasting it.
I guess its different with
I guess it's different with certain people. I know people that work well with music and some that can't tolerate with any noise. Sometimes though I catch myself being a bit inconsiderate since I usually play my music loudly, and yes people do get annoyed. I also notice that it depends with the certain music I play, which affects my ability to do work. At times when I'm doing both, I get easily distracted and my pace dies down. Other times, it does get me through it. It depends with certain people...
Creativity
I'm part of a Creative Writing class at school where we are allowed to listen to music. It's one of the only classes I have where I can do this and I find it rather relaxing. Something about music is inspiring to a creative mind, and I find that it's much easier to write stories and poetry while listening to Iron and Wine than it is while I'm sitting in dead silence. I do however, agree with the point of having no music in classes where concentration is important. The fact that I'm allowed to listen to my ipod during chemistry is what's giving me a low B, because I spend 90% of the time watching Star Trek, and 10% paying attention. In that case, a "no music" policy is clearly understandable.
I, myself listen to music
I, myself listen to music when I study or do my homework and I do see the decrease in productivity. At the same time sometimes it helps me keep my energy levels up when I'm tired and just makes me work harder
i've never heard of that
i've never heard of that before, "no-music" policies... thats very interesting, and definitely a good idea! i kinda hope that my school would do something like that. i can never tell if my class mates are actually listening to me.